Petty Loyalty: How One Brit Turned a Mistaken Email into a Cat Treat Bonanza at Tractor Supply
Have you ever gotten an email so random, so persistent, that you found yourself tempted to do something—well, just a little bit petty? That’s exactly what happened to one UK Redditor, u/P-e-t-e, whose email was mysteriously used at America’s beloved (but, as it turns out, somewhat misleadingly named) Tractor Supply Co. Instead of tractors, he found himself collecting loyalty points on everything from dog collars to cement, all thanks to a stranger’s repeated email faux pas.
But rather than block the spam, our hero took an unexpected path: a journey into the world of petty revenge—one bag of cat treats at a time. And when Reddit’s r/PettyRevenge community got wind of it, the fur—and the puns—flew.
The Curious Case of the Tractor-less Tractor Supply
It all began in 2021 (or, as the OP later discovered, as far back as 2019), when u/P-e-t-e started receiving order surveys from Tractor Supply, a retail chain he’d never heard of. Living in the UK, his only exposure to tractors was likely limited to the occasional countryside drive—not exactly prime Tractor Supply territory. A bit of sleuthing revealed that, despite the name, Tractor Supply doesn’t actually sell tractors, a revelation that left more than one commenter chuckling. As u/Clovernover quipped, “They don't even sell tractors 😂,” with others sharing their own letdowns at the store’s misleading moniker.
Initially, Pete assumed it was a one-off mistake—maybe someone across the pond typo’d their email at checkout. But the emails kept coming, and as u/pokeypuppy51 and u/Bruyere62 pointed out, having an early, simple Gmail address is an open invitation for strangers to sign you up for everything from farm supplies to dating sites (hello, FarmersOnly.com).
When Life Gives You Loyalty Points, Buy Cat Treats
Most of us would’ve just clicked “unsubscribe.” But Pete, in the true spirit of r/PettyRevenge, decided it was time for a little fun. He realized he could register a Tractor Supply account with his email, which instantly connected him to the in-store loyalty account the American stranger was unwittingly filling with points.
Instead of letting those points go to waste—or worse, gifting the mystery shopper their precious $10 discounts—Pete opted to cash in for something a bit more mischievous: cat treat vouchers. Every time a new order landed in his inbox, he’d log in, snatch up the points, and convert them into treats. As the vouchers piled up (eight and counting, at last update), Pete mused about the day the account holder might be confronted at checkout: “Would you like to redeem your 15 free bags of cat treats today?” Cue the confused looks and possibly a newfound respect for email accuracy.
Reddit’s community adored the idea, with u/CoderJoe1 asking, “Are you kitten me?” and u/victorpaparomeo2020 declaring it “purrrrfect.” The puns were almost as plentiful as the cat treats.
Community Reactions: Puns, Plans, and Petty Solidarity
The post quickly turned into a playground for witty wordplay and shared tales of mistaken digital identity. But there was substance, too. The most upvoted comment from u/Left_Ad3575 wondered if Pete could donate the treats to a US shelter, sparking a thread of ideas about using the mishap for good. OP himself responded enthusiastically, exploring whether he could send rewards to a US rescue, and other commenters chimed in with logistical tips and encouragement (u/Independent-Heart-17 even suggested emailing customer service to arrange a direct donation).
Others empathized, sharing their own stories of digital doppelgängers. u/Grrerrb recounted receiving a stranger’s vacation plans, while u/JeffTheNth turned a pizza points mix-up into a personal pizza party. As u/pokeypuppy51 put it, “Thank you. Truly. face twists into an evil smile, while drumming fingers together and releasing a maniacal laugh that echoes through the chambers of my cold, black heart.”
Of course, not everyone saw the act as true “revenge.” Some, like u/badmind88 and u/agmccall, argued the original shopper probably didn’t care about the rewards, either using a fake email or remaining blissfully unaware of the points piling up in cyberspace. Still, OP countered that he’d been getting these emails for years—hardly a one-time fluke.
The Legend of Nigel, the 666lb Pregnant Gorilla
No tale of internet mischief is complete without a little absurdity—and Pete delivered, registering a “pet” on the account named Nigel, a 666lb pregnant gorilla “weirdly obsessed with cat treats.” This detail slayed the comments section; u/teamdogemama confessed to waking her dog from laughter, and u/ImperfectTapestry simply exclaimed, “Oh, Nigel!”
It’s a fitting capstone to a saga that’s equal parts petty, wholesome, and hilariously surreal. While we may never know if the original shopper is haunted by visions of endless cat treats or Nigel’s dietary needs, the story stands as a master class in how to turn digital annoyance into entertainment—and maybe, just maybe, a bit of good for shelter cats.
Conclusion: When Life Gives You Spam, Make Mischief
So, what’s the moral of this story? Maybe it’s this: Secure your accounts, double-check your email, and never underestimate the creativity of someone with a simple Gmail and a penchant for petty revenge.
Have you ever received someone else’s emails or loyalty rewards? Did you ignore them, seek revenge, or find a way to do some good? Share your tales of inbox mix-ups, petty victories, and accidental generosity in the comments below—bonus points for puns and gorilla-sized imagination!
Original Reddit Post: Use my email address in-store, I’ll spend your loyalty reward points on cat treats